I'm Mefat Shabani, a cybersecurity manager in financial services with more than 10 years in application security and DevSecOps. I write the reviews and comparisons on Online Security Hub, and below is where their facts come from.
Two kinds of product pages
Every product on the site falls into one of two groups, and the page tells you which.
- Products with a verdict, Recommended or Not recommended. I give a verdict only to products I have used myself, on my own devices. Products I still use every day also carry the label "I use this".
- Products without a verdict. These pages are built from public sources only. They show the date I last updated the facts and say plainly that they are "not a hands-on review".
Comparison pages follow the same rule: a product gets a verdict there only if I have used it.
Hands-on use
For a product with a verdict, I install it on my own devices and use it in daily life, the way you would. The verdict rests on that use and on the public facts in the next section.
I test on Windows, macOS, iOS and Android. A product gets a verdict only after I have used it as my daily tool for at least two weeks. Password managers, for example, each import the same 291-login vault and then replace my usual manager for two weeks or more. I have tested 15 password managers and 15 antivirus programs this way, and dozens of VPNs over the years.
Facts from public sources
Most facts on the site come from sources anyone can check. Each one has a link and a "checked" date next to it, so you can see how fresh it is. The sources I use most:
- The vendor's own website, help centre, pricing page and privacy policy
- Independent security audits, with the name of the auditor and the date
- Results from independent test labs such as AV-TEST, AV-Comparatives and SE Labs, with the test month
- Release notes and changelogs, with the version number
- Public vulnerability records (CVE entries) and published security research
- Court records and regulator decisions, such as fines or settlements
A vendor's claim stays a claim. If a VPN company says it keeps no logs, I write "the company says" until an independent audit backs it up. If I can't find a source for a fact, I leave it out.
What I compare in each category
| Category | What I look at |
|---|---|
| VPNs | Speed on nearby and distant servers, extra delay (latency), the protocol used (such as WireGuard), the country the company is based in and whether it shares intelligence with others (Five Eyes), audited no-logs claims, and first-year and renewal prices. |
| Antivirus | Detection and false-alarm scores from the latest AV-TEST and AV-Comparatives rounds, the effect on the computer (scan times, processor and memory use, start-up time), renewal prices, the owner and country, certifications such as ISO 27001 and SOC 2, and past incidents. |
| Password managers | The country the company is based in, open source code, independent audits (who and when), breach history, how fast known flaws were fixed, autofill on real banking, government and shopping sites, and renewal prices. |
| Browsers | Tracker and ad blocking by default, fingerprinting protection, what data goes back to the vendor, whether sync is end-to-end encrypted, extension support, audits, how fast security fixes ship, and built-in extras such as AI or crypto features. |
| Ad blockers | What Chrome's Manifest V3 changes took away, filter lists, paid "acceptable ads" programmes, memory use, supported browsers and who owns the blocker. |
| Cloud storage | End-to-end encryption (whether the provider can read your files), where files are stored, price per terabyte, file versions and recovery after ransomware, controls on shared links, family plans, breaches and file scanning, and audits. |
Speed and performance figures
Speed and system-impact numbers change with your connection, your hardware and the server you pick. Every table of figures names who measured them, where and when. Use them to compare products roughly. Your own results will differ.
The figures in my comparisons come from my own runs:
- VPNs: speed tests from a 1 Gbps fibre connection in the EU, using WireGuard (or the provider's own protocol) to servers in Europe and the US, repeated over several sessions across two weeks of daily use.
- Antivirus: one Windows 11 PC built for testing (AMD Ryzen 9 9950X, 64 GB of DDR5 RAM, a 2 TB NVMe SSD), so the hardware never slows a product down. I time full and quick scans and note how much each program slows everyday work. Detection rates come from the independent labs, with the test month.
- Password managers: the same 291-login vault in every manager, used daily for at least two weeks, with autofill, sync and import checked on every system.
What I don't do
- I don't sell rankings. No vendor can pay for a verdict, a better position or a kinder sentence.
- I don't run a malware lab. Detection scores come from the independent labs named above, with links.
- I don't invent benchmarks, screenshots or user numbers. A figure without a source does not go on the site.
- I don't call a comparison "tested" when I have only compared public facts.
A vendor can ask me to review its product. I may say yes or no, and the verdict stays mine either way.
How often pages are rechecked
Links on the site are checked automatically every week, so broken or moved sources show up quickly. Prices and facts are checked by hand, and the "checked" date on each page changes only after I have done that.
I recheck prices and key facts on my comparisons every three months. A breach, a sale of the company, a new owner or a big price change gets a recheck straight away, and the page shows the new "Updated" date.
When I change a verdict, I say so on the page and explain why.
Corrections
If you find a wrong fact, an old price or a broken link, please tell me through the contact form and include the address of the page. I check the source, fix the page if I got it wrong and update the "checked" date. Vendors can use the same form to point out errors. A correction from a vendor needs a public source, just like any other fact.
How the site makes money
Some pages contain affiliate links. If you buy through one, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never decides a verdict or a position. The full details are on the disclosure page.