The problem
Most cloud storage rankings sort by storage per dollar and leave out the one question that matters for private files: who holds the encryption keys?
Nearly every service says your files are "encrypted". That is true for all nine services in this comparison. The difference is who can unlock them. With Dropbox, Google Drive and OneDrive, the company holds the keys on standard personal accounts, so it can read, scan and hand over your files. With zero-knowledge (end-to-end encrypted) storage, your device locks the files before upload and the provider only sees scrambled data.
Then there is the free-storage trap. A 15 GB free plan that is shared with your email and photos fills up fast, and the price jump to the next tier is where the money is made. Several of the cheapest options also move the privacy features behind an add-on or a higher plan, so the headline price tells you little.
The last problem is that many "best cloud storage" lists are written by affiliate sites. I take no commissions and use no coupons here. Where I give a price, it comes from the vendor's page and I say when the sources disagree.
The Answer
This comparison covers 9 services: OneDrive, Google Drive, iCloud Drive, Dropbox, Proton Drive, Filen, Internxt, Sync.com and pCloud. I compare them on encryption, hosting location, free storage, price per terabyte, file recovery, sharing controls, family plans, incidents, audits and open source. I have not tested these services myself. Every fact comes from a vendor page, an audit, or press coverage, and carries a link. Prices were checked on 25 August 2026 and change often, so confirm them at checkout.
My short answer: for private files, pick a zero-knowledge service. Proton Drive is my first choice. Filen is the cheapest strong one. If you live inside Apple's world, iCloud with Advanced Data Protection is a real option, with one big exception for UK users.
Cloud Storage Services List
These are the nine I compared, grouped by who holds your keys.
- Zero-knowledge by default: Proton Drive, Filen, Internxt, Sync.com.
- Zero-knowledge only if you add or switch something on: iCloud Drive (Advanced Data Protection), pCloud (Crypto add-on), Dropbox (Advanced plan folder option).
- Provider holds the keys on personal plans: OneDrive, Google Drive.
Cloud Storage Services I Recommend
- Proton Drive: best private all-rounder. Proton AG is in Switzerland and says files and file names are encrypted on your device before upload. The free plan gives 5 GB. Drive Plus (200 GB) costs $29.88 for the first year, then $47.88 a year, and it keeps previous file versions for 10 years. Share links can have a password and an expiry date. The code is public, and Proton says Drive has been audited by Securitum; the reports I could find are from 2021 (web app) and 2022 (mobile apps), as one independent review notes. That is old. The downsides: sharing files over 5 GB needs a paid plan, and the plan card and Drive page disagree on whether free storage is 1 GB or 5 GB, so check at sign-up.
- Filen: best value for strong encryption. Filen is run from Germany and says its servers are all in Germany, in ISO 27001 certified data centres. It says everything is zero-knowledge and that all its apps are open source. Plans are 1.99 EUR a month for 200 GiB, 8.99 EUR for 2 TiB and 39.99 EUR for 10 TiB, and plans stack on one account. The downside is trust evidence. I found no independent audit listed on its pages, and its security page says it no longer runs a public bug bounty. It also did not state the free storage amount on the pages I read.
- Internxt: best for budget and lifetime deals. Internxt is a Spanish company, and reviews place it in Valencia. It gives 1 GB free and sells annual and lifetime plans with 1, 2 or 5 TB. Its code is on GitHub, and it says Securitum audited it in 2024 and that it holds ISO 27001:2022. Those are its own claims, so read the report before you rely on them. File versioning was missing for a long time. PCWorld reports that Internxt told it versioning is now on the Premium and Ultimate plans. Reviewers also complain about slow downloads and limited sharing.
- Sync.com: best zero-knowledge for the whole account, if you accept its age. Sync says core storage is end-to-end encrypted by default, and file data sits in Canada or the United States depending on your region. The free plan is 5 GB. Reviews put the 2 TB Solo Basic plan at about $96 a year, but one source lists a much lower price, so check the pricing page. The downsides are real: its privacy policy says some optional features may process files at a lower encryption level and that it uses advertising cookies, there is no native Linux app, and I found no open-source clients or published audit.
- iCloud Drive with Advanced Data Protection: best for Apple-only households outside the UK. By default Apple holds the keys. Switch on Advanced Data Protection and iCloud Drive, Photos and Backup become end-to-end encrypted. You get 5 GB free, and 2 TB costs $9.99 a month. The catches: shared items and "anyone with the link" sharing are not covered, some metadata stays under standard protection, and if you lose access Apple cannot recover the data. In the UK the option is gone. Apple pulled Advanced Data Protection from UK users in February 2025 after government pressure, and a new tribunal complaint was filed in August 2026 without a ruling.
Cloud Storage Services I Do Not Recommend (for private files)
None of these is dangerous for holiday photos or school homework. I would not put passport scans, tax records or client documents in them.
Google Drive is the most convenient and the least private. Free users get 15 GB shared across Drive, Gmail and Photos, and the paid tiers shown are bundled with AI features (2 TB is 9.99 EUR a month). Standard personal accounts are not end-to-end encrypted, and Google earns most of its money from advertising. Its policy says it does not show personalised ads based on Drive content, but that can change if you link data to other Google services. Google also scans for child abuse material with hash matching. The risk is the lockout: reports describe whole accounts, covering Gmail, Photos and Drive, disabled after false positives. On the plus side, ransomware detection and bulk restore became generally available in March 2026, with about 25 days of revisions.
OneDrive makes sense if you pay for Microsoft 365 anyway. Microsoft says each file gets its own AES-256 key held in Azure Key Vault, which is standard encryption: Microsoft can still access content. The privacy statement allows personalised ads based on your activity. Files Restore covers the last 30 days and suggests a restore date when it detects ransomware, but only for Microsoft 365 subscribers. Personal Vault adds a second lock for a small folder, and without a Personal or Family plan you can store only three files in it. It is a separate area, not an encrypted drive.
Dropbox has the smallest free plan here (2 GB) and, for individuals, the weakest privacy. Files are encrypted at rest with AES-256, but standard accounts are not zero-knowledge. End-to-end encryption is a folder option on the Advanced plan only, which is built for teams of three or more. Files are stored in US data centres, and only eligible team plans can pick Australia, the EU, Japan or the UK. Recovery is good: 30 days on Plus, 180 on Standard, one year on Advanced. The incident record is the problem. In April 2024 an attacker reached the Dropbox Sign production system and accessed emails and usernames of all users, plus hashed passwords, API keys and MFA data for some. Dropbox found no sign that signed documents were accessed. In December 2023, an AI setting that was on by default alarmed users; the CEO said no data is sent passively to third-party AI.
pCloud is a Swiss company known for its lifetime deals. Standard storage is not zero-knowledge. pCloud Encryption protects only a "Crypto" folder, and the 500 GB, 2 TB and 10 TB lifetime plans do not include it (Premium 159 EUR, Premium Plus 379 EUR, Ultra 1,099 EUR at the current sale). Only the 3 TB bundle at 579 EUR does. Reviews price Crypto at 49.99 EUR a year or about 125 EUR for life. You can choose EU or US storage. Reviews also report that ETH Zurich researchers published encryption flaws in October 2024 that pCloud called theoretical, and Gizmodo mentions a February 2026 bug that exposed other users' file names. I found no confirmed data breach. If you already own a lifetime plan and want private files, use the Crypto folder. If you are buying new, I would pick a service that is zero-knowledge from the start.
Cloud Storage Data Sheet
Compare all 9
Included or strongPartial, add-on or weakerNot available or weak
| Attribute | OneDrive | Google Drive | iCloud Drive | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Owner | Microsoft (USA) | Google (USA) | Apple (USA) | Dropbox, Inc. (USA) | Proton AG (Switzerland) | Filen (Germany) | Internxt (Spain) | Sync.com, Inc. (Canada) | pCloud International AG (CH) |
| Business model | Subscription, ads possible | Ads company, subscription | Hardware + subscription | Subscription | Subscription | Subscription | Subscription, lifetime | Subscription, ad cookies | Subscription, lifetime |
| Platforms | Web, Win, Mac, iOS, Android | Web, Win, Mac, iOS, Android | Apple, Windows, web | Web, Win, Mac, iOS, Android | Web, Win, Mac, iOS, Android | Web, Win, Mac, Linux, mobile | Web, Win, Mac, Linux, mobile | No native Linux app | Web, desktop, mobile |
| Account needed | Microsoft account | Google account | Apple Account | Email account | Proton account | Email account | Email account | Email account | Email account |
| End-to-end by default | No | No | No (ADP optional) | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No (Crypto add-on) |
| Zero-knowledge option | Personal Vault only | Workspace plans only | Yes, Advanced Data Prot. | Advanced plan folders | Included | Included | Included | Included | Crypto folder, extra cost |
| File names encrypted | No | No | With ADP | No | Yes | Not confirmed | Not confirmed | Not confirmed | Crypto folder only |
| Provider can scan files | Yes | Yes | Yes, unless ADP | Yes | No | No | No | No (optional features) | Yes, outside Crypto |
| Personalised ads | Allowed by policy | Not from Drive content | No | No | No | No | No | Ad cookies on site | Says no tracking |
| Account-lock risk | Reported | Reported (abuse scans) | Low reports found | Low reports found | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low |
| Data location | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | US; EU etc. on teams | Switzerland | Germany (own claim) | EU (sources differ) | Canada or US | EU (Lux.) or US |
| Region choice | Not confirmed | No | No | Teams plans only | No | No | No | Yes | Yes |
| Legal base | US law | US law | US law; UK ADP removed | US law | Swiss law | German/EU law | Spanish/EU law | Canadian/US law | Swiss law (CLOUD Act risk) |
| Free storage | Free tier (check size) | 15 GB shared | 5 GB | 2 GB | 5 GB (1 GB on plan card) | Free plan, size not stated | 1 GB | 5 GB | Not stated |
| Entry paid plan | $1.99/mo, 100 GB | EUR 1.99/mo, 100 GB | $0.99/mo, 50 GB | Plus EUR 9.99/mo | $47.88/yr, 200 GB | EUR 1.99/mo, 200 GiB | About $30/yr, 1 TB | Not confirmed | Lifetime EUR 159, 500 GB |
| About 2 TB price | Family $12.99/mo, shared | EUR 9.99/mo (AI Plus) | $9.99/mo | Plus EUR 9.99/mo | Duo $179.88/yr, 2 users | EUR 8.99/mo | Premium plan, varies | About $96/yr | Lifetime EUR 379 |
| Lifetime option | No | No | No | No | No | Not confirmed | Yes | No | Yes |
| Largest personal tier | 6 TB (Premium) | 5 TB | 12 TB | Not confirmed | 2 TB (Duo) | 10 TiB, stackable | 5 TB, stackable | 6 TB (Pro) | 10 TB lifetime |
| Version history | Per-file (not confirmed) | About 25 days restore | Not confirmed | 30/180/365 days by plan | 10 years (Plus) | Not confirmed | Higher tiers only | 180-365 days (Teams) | 30 days rewind |
| Ransomware restore | Yes, 30 days (M365) | Yes, since Mar 2026 | Not confirmed | Rewind by plan | Via versions | Not confirmed | Not confirmed | Via history | Rewind 30 days |
| Link password | Not confirmed | No | No (link not E2EE) | Not confirmed | Yes | Not confirmed | Yes | Yes (Teams) | Not confirmed |
| Link expiry | Not confirmed | Yes | Not confirmed | Not confirmed | Yes | Not confirmed | Not confirmed | Yes (Teams) | Not confirmed |
| Family plan | Yes, shared 2 TB | Via Google One | Yes, Family Sharing | Not confirmed | Duo (2 users) | Stackable plans | None found | None found | Yes, up to 5 |
| Notable incident | None found | Account lockouts reported | UK ADP withdrawn 2025 | Dropbox Sign breach 2024 | None found | None found | None found | None found | Bug Feb 2026; ETH paper 2024 |
| AI/data controversy | None found | None found | None found | AI default setting 2023 | None found | None found | None found | None found | None found |
| Open-source clients | No | No | No | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Not listed | Partial (SDKs) |
| Independent audit | None published | None published | None published | None published | Securitum 2021/2022 | None listed | Securitum 2024 (own claim) | None found | None found |
| Certification | Not checked | Not checked | Not checked | Not checked | SOC 2 Type II 2025 | ISO 27001 data centres | ISO 27001:2022 (own claim) | Not stated | Not stated |
| Warrant canary | No | No | No | No | Not confirmed | Yes | Not confirmed | Not confirmed | Not confirmed |
| My verdict for private files | Casual use only | Casual use only | OK with ADP (not UK) | Not for private files | Recommended | Recommended | Recommended, budget | Recommended with caveats | Only with Crypto |
| Best for | Microsoft 365 users | Android, email users | Apple-only households | Teams, long recovery | Private all-rounder | Cheap strong E2EE | Lifetime, budget | Whole-account E2EE | Existing lifetime owners |
Encryption: What "Zero-Knowledge" Means in Practice
Zero-knowledge means the keys never leave your devices. Proton, Filen, Internxt and Sync.com say they work this way for all stored files. The trade-off: if you forget your password and lose your recovery key, nobody can get your files back. Apple says the same about Advanced Data Protection: if you lose access, Apple cannot help recover the data.
Read the exceptions. Sync.com says some optional features may temporarily process specific files. Apple's ADP leaves iCloud Mail, Contacts and Calendars outside end-to-end encryption, and sharing only stays encrypted when everyone has ADP on. Web access also changes: iCloud.com is disabled by default under ADP.
Zero-knowledge also costs features. A provider that cannot read your files cannot search inside them on its servers, preview them as easily or let a web editor open them without your browser doing the decrypting. Proton does offer online Docs and Sheets, which shows it can be done.
Where Your Files Are Stored
- EU: Filen (Germany, by its own account), Internxt (Spain-based; reviews disagree on whether all storage is in the EU). pCloud lets you pick Luxembourg.
- Switzerland: Proton is based there and cites Swiss privacy law. pCloud is registered in Switzerland too, but one review warns that Swiss headquarters do not give blanket immunity from US CLOUD Act requests.
- Canada or US: Sync.com, by your choice of region.
- US: Dropbox by default.
Jurisdiction matters less when files are zero-knowledge, because a warrant can only return scrambled data. It matters a lot for OneDrive, Google Drive and standard iCloud.
Price per Terabyte
Prices below are the vendor figures I found. Compare them over a year.
- Internxt: annual plans from about $30 a year for 1 TB, per Cloudwards, so the cheapest ongoing price. Lifetime prices vary by sale.
- Sync.com: about $96 a year for 2 TB, around $48 per TB.
- Filen: 8.99 EUR a month for 2 TiB, about 54 EUR per TB per year.
- Google Drive and iCloud: 2 TB for 9.99 EUR or $9.99 a month, roughly 60 per TB per year. iCloud also offers 6 TB for $29.99.
- Proton Drive: Duo gives 2 TB for 2 users at $179.88 a year, around $90 per TB. The 200 GB Drive Plus tier is cheap for small needs.
- OneDrive: Personal is 1 TB for $9.99 a month, or $120 a year, with the Office apps included.
- pCloud: lifetime, 2 TB once for 379 EUR. It pays off after about 3.5 years against Google or Apple, if the company lasts.
File Versioning and Ransomware Recovery
Ransomware encrypts your files and syncing then copies the damage to the cloud. Version history is your way back, so look at how long it goes back.
- Proton Drive Plus: 10 years.
- Dropbox: 30, 180 or 365 days by plan.
- Sync.com: 180 days on Teams 1 TB, 365 days on larger Teams plans. I could not confirm the personal figures on that page.
- OneDrive: 30-day restore with ransomware detection (Microsoft 365 subscribers).
- pCloud: 30 days of rewind.
- Google Drive: bulk restore with ransomware detection, about 25 days of revisions.
- Internxt: versioning on higher tiers only, per PCWorld. Filen: I could not confirm its version limits.
Sharing Links, Passwords and Expiry
Proton Drive links can carry a password and an expiry date. Internxt lists password-protected sharing. Sync.com includes password links and expiry in its Advanced share controls, shown on the Teams plans. Google Drive lets you set an expiry on access. Apple's "anyone with the link" sharing is outside Advanced Data Protection. Tip: a link with a password and a short expiry is safer than a public link that lives forever.
Family Plans
OneDrive's Family plan is $12.99 a month for 2 TB shared. Proton Duo covers 2 users. pCloud's family plan covers up to 5 users for one price. iCloud+ storage can be shared with family members. Filen sells plans that stack on one account rather than a family tier. I found no family plan for Internxt or Sync.com.
Breaches and File Scanning
Two kinds of risk exist. One is a company breach. Dropbox is the clearest case in this list (the Dropbox Sign incident in 2024). I found no confirmed customer data breach for the other eight, but the pCloud bug and encryption research above are worth knowing.
The other is scanning. Google scans for abuse material and can lock a whole account on a match. With zero-knowledge storage a provider cannot scan your file contents on its servers at all, which is a feature for privacy and a limit for the provider's own moderation.
Open Source and Audits
Open source lets researchers check the code, but that does not mean anyone has. Proton, Filen and Internxt publish code, with Internxt on GitHub and Proton's web apps on GitHub. For audits, Securitum is named for Proton Drive (2021, 2022) and, by Internxt's own account, Internxt (2024). Proton also completed its first SOC 2 Type II audit in July 2025, which covers company controls, not Drive's code. pCloud's GitHub has a console client, a sync library and SDKs, not the full desktop and mobile apps. Dropbox, Google, Microsoft and Apple do not publish their client code.
8 Tips for Choosing Cloud Storage
- Decide what you store. Photos and school files can live anywhere. Passports, taxes and work documents need zero-knowledge.
- Check where the keys live, not where the marketing says "secure".
- Use a strong unique password and 2FA. A zero-knowledge service is only as safe as your password.
- Save your recovery key offline. No recovery key, no files.
- Look at the version history window before you rely on it against ransomware.
- Compare the second-year price. Promotions drop away.
- Check the plan, not the brand. pCloud's lifetime plans and Dropbox's end-to-end option show how a feature can sit one tier up.
- Keep a second copy. Sync is not backup, and one locked account should not cost you everything.
FAQ
Is iCloud Drive end-to-end encrypted?
Not by default. You need to turn on Advanced Data Protection. It is not available to new UK users.
Which service gives the most free storage?
Google Drive, with 15 GB shared with Gmail and Photos. Among the private ones, Proton and Sync.com give 5 GB (Proton's own pages differ), and Internxt gives 1 GB.
Is Dropbox safe?
It uses strong encryption in transit and at rest, but standard accounts are not zero-knowledge and it had the 2024 Dropbox Sign breach.
Can a provider recover my files if I forget my password?
Not on zero-knowledge services. Keep your recovery key.
Is a lifetime plan a good idea?
It can save money, but you rely on the company staying in business for years. Check what the plan includes, especially encryption.
Still not sure? Tell me what you store and which devices you use in the comments.



Comments 0
No comments yet. Questions, corrections and your own experience are all welcome.